New Braunfels was founded by German immigrants in 1845. Over the years, this city has grown into a prosperous and diverse community with a rich history and plenty of cultural events.
In addition to its well-preserved historic districts, charming architecture and plentiful natural areas, New Braunfels’ diverse heritage makes for a delicious food scene!
Are you planning on visiting or moving to New Braunfels? Here’s our list of the best New Braunfels restaurants in this city.
1. McAdoo's Seafood Co.
Opened in 2009, McAdoo’s Seafood Co. is housed in the building of a century-old U.S. Post Office, built on Treasury Secretary William McAdoo’s watch. What makes this restaurant amazing is its food and its building having so much history.
In addition, McAdoo’s has some of the best sea food dishes in all of Texas Hill Country. Whether it's oysters, fried shrimp, cocktails, shrimp and grits or a seafood fondue, they have the best service and food possible.
2. Myron’s Prime Steakhouse
A visit to New Braunfels wouldn’t be complete without eating at a steakhouse and Myron’s Prime Steakhouse is one of the best options in the entire city.
This high-end restaurant has everything a meat lover would enjoy. All the well-known dishes from a steak to a simple salad are elevated to give you the best and good food, wine and service. In addition, the place is based in a restored old-school theater, adding to its ambiance.
3. Alpine Haus Restaurant
The city of New Braunfels was founded by German immigrants in the mid-19th century. This heritage is still celebrated today and there’s no better place in Texas to have some excellent German food than Alpine Haus.
In this restaurant, you’ll be able to taste traditional German dishes such as sausage samplers, a Jaeger schnitzel or a Rinder Rouladen with a serving of delicious sauerkraut. You’ll also be able to enjoy American dishes from a Reuben sandwich to a piece of Black Forest cake.
4. La Cosecha Mexican Table
New Braunfels has a rich Hispanic heritage and one of the best places to have authentic Mexican cuisine is in La Cosecha. This restaurant was opened in 2019 by Wiggins Hospitality Group, the owners of McAdoo’s Seafood Co.
The name translates to “the harvest” which is very fitting, given that La Cosecha’s main goal is utilizing seasonal and local Texas ingredients. Plus, its family-friendly setting makes for the perfect breakfast or lunch spot for large groups.
5. Rudy’s Country Store And BBQ
Texans have a long history with barbecue. This traditional North American dish was influenced both by African American and German customs. There’s no better place to taste a traditional Texan BBQ in New Braunfels than in Rudy’s Country Store.
Rudy’s first opened in 1900 as an old-fashioned country store in the community of Leon Springs. Over the years, they expanded and opened 36 locations across Texas. Although they didn’t add barbecue to their menu until 1989, this is still one of their biggest attractions.
Whether you’re looking for a simple but delicious sandwich, ribs, or a juicy brisket, you’ll find it at Rudy’s. After all, this BBQ restaurant offers about 12 different options of meat, served with anything from beans, coleslaw, sweet corn, potato salad or even smoked potatoes.
6. The Gruene Door
If you’re looking for a casual, fine-dining restaurant in New Braunfels, The Gruene Door is the way to go! Every single item on the menu is made 100% from scratch by the in-house chefs. You’ll be able to enjoy anything from shrimp and grits with bacon sauce and cheddar cheese to an excellent fried duck confit.
There’s a reason why The Gruene Door remains a favorite among both locals and visitors since its opening in 2009. Open for lunch and dinner, this is the perfect spot for a romantic dinner, a private party, or a low-key night out with friends.
7. Muck & Fuss
If you’re in search of the perfect burger, you should visit New Braunfels’ Muck And Fuss Craft Beer and Burgers. You cannot only find all kinds of sandwiches, burgers, and fries, but also tacos, burger salads, and even crab cakes. Moreover, Muck And Fuss’s bar offers about 20 different options of craft beer on tap.
Open from breakfast to dinner, Muck and Fuss is one of the best places to eat in New Braunfels. Plus, its dog-friendly shaded courtyard is the perfect spot to enjoy a couple of beers and relax.
8. Buttermilk Cafe
If you’re looking for a hearty breakfast, Buttermilk Cafe should be top of your list. Serving breakfast and lunch from 7 a.m. to well past noon, this upscale cafe has something for everyone.
Buttermilk Cafe’s menu includes crustless quiches, panini bread, bagels topped with anything from cream cheese to cured salmon, meatloaf and even traditional shrimp and grits. Whether you come to have breakfast or dinner, you will be satisfied for the rest of the day.
Bottom Line
New Braunfels, TX, offers a unique blend of cultural richness which plays a crucial part in its diverse food scene. In this city, you can find anything from German and Mexican-inspired restaurants to upscaled seafood joints.
Now that you know the best places to eat in New Braunfels, you can make the most out of your time in this wonderful city!
Thinking about moving to New Braunfels? Contact Limestone Country Properties today! We can help you find the perfect house in this city.
